Four years later, on June 26th, 2015, the Supreme Court made it the law of the land.
I was on a boat to Fire Island when the ruling came through. A group of us had been following the news anxiously, braced for disappointment the way you brace yourself when you've been disappointed before. Nobody wanted to hope too hard. We had learned not to.
But the news was good. Better than good.
We got on the ferry with limited marriage rights and arrived on Fire Island with full marriage rights. It was surreal. Quiet at first — the kind of quiet that happens when something you've wanted for so long finally arrives and you don't quite know what to do with it. And then not quiet at all.
The phone started ringing almost immediately after the New York ruling, and I think I understood why.
I was one of the only photographers anywhere with same-sex couples front and center on my website. I had already photographed commitment ceremonies — unions that were meaningful in every human sense even if the law hadn't caught up yet — and I had put those images where everyone could see them, right alongside my straight couples. No separate site. No different name. No hedging.
This was not the norm. Many photographers who had those images hid them — creating separate websites under different names because they feared a backlash from straight clients. I understood that fear. I just couldn't do it. These couples deserved to be treated as equal in my marketing because they were equal. Full stop. And I think potential clients noticed.
They came from all over. Couples from states where it still wasn't legal, making the trip to New York City specifically to get married here. Many of them were nervous in a way that broke my heart a little. Reticent about holding hands in public, hesitant to kiss for the camera, so accustomed to hiding that the simple act of being visible felt dangerous even on their wedding day.
And then a New Yorker would walk by.
It happened almost every single time. A stranger on the street would see what was happening, two people, clearly just married, clearly in love, and they would stop. They would cheer. They would applaud. They would blow kisses. New York City opened its arms to these couples in a way that thrilled me every single time I witnessed it.
One afternoon I was with two men who had just gotten married, shooting portraits on the street, when an elderly woman stopped us. She asked if she could give something to the couple. They said yes. And she sang "At Last" for them, right there on the sidewalk.
We all cried. Happy tears. One of my favorite memories in 25 years of doing this work.
After the national ruling in 2015, the inquiries came from even further afield — from countries where marriage equality was still years away, from places where being openly gay carried real risk. I've photographed couples from all over the world because of it. People who came to New York City specifically because here, for a few days, they could be fully themselves.
That is a privilege I don't take lightly.